Opinion: McNabb Trade Alters Redskin’s Future

Longtime Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb was traded to the Washington Redskins Sunday for two draft picks. (Courtesy of ESPN.com)

Every year in the NFL there is that one offseason deal that completely changes the outlook and appearance of a team. Even though it doesn’t work out the way that team intended it to, it still is a big deal at the time. For some reason, that team is most of the time the Washington Redskins.

Last year they pulled out that big checkbook Dan Snyder has and signed big defensive tackle Albert Haynesworth. What a bust that deal was, Haynesworth sat on the sideline a majority of the year. There have been several other examples before last year of when the Redskins have thrown money down players’ throats to see them completely fail once they arrive at Washington.

However, this year is different. The main office is making big money deals, but now they are deals with more thought. No more going out into the free agency market and getting the biggest name in the league simply by giving them the biggest contract. Snyder and Bruce Allen, the money and brains of the organization, have gone out and gotten an experienced, successful quarterback, the most important component of a team Washington has failed to find within the last decade.

I’m talking about the Redskins acquiring quarterback Donovan McNabb. A respected quarterback can provide the leadership and poise the Redskins have been missing seemingly forever, especially after seeing the turmoil previous quarterback Jason Campbell went through last season. McNabb has six Pro Bowls and five NFC championship games under his belt. This is exactly what the Redskins have needed since Snyder made his first bonehead decision in not keeping Brad Johnson. Having a quarterback of McNabb’s status means the team can finally address other issues.

As mentioned earlier, Campbell had a terrible season last year, thanks in large part to the offensive line. It was terrible, resulting in every single game having Campbell being knocked to the ground. With McNabb, the team now does not have to draft a quarterback and worry about what would have been either Sam Bradford or Jimmy Clausen becoming a bust.

An offensive lineman would also be ideal. McNabb may be good, but no one will succeed behind the offensive line of the last season’s Redskins.

If not an offensive lineman, then a tall wide receiver would be a welcome addition through the draft. Aside from Santana Moss, the Redskins really have no wide receivers for McNabb to look for. Even with that, Moss does not have the same electrifying game pace as he once did when he arrived at the nation’s capitol. Sure, Devin Thomas and Malcolm Kelly had some impressive moments, but McNabb still needs a big threat to unleash his cannon too.

Regardless of what the Redskins do with their fourth overall pick, the fact that they have satisfied their overdue need at the quarterback position means they can move on to other things. The quarterback is the most important position of the offense. He is the field general physically, emotionally, cognitively and in so many other ways. Not having a reliable quarterback can lead to several problems, as you can tell by the recent history of the Redskins.

That is no more though. Donovan McNabb has arrived in Washington and solved their problems. Seriously, do not be surprised if the Redskins end up taking a wildcard playoff spot. McNabb could very well be that big of a difference maker for the team.

  • Rod

    why are you suggesting a WR? , Devin Thomas 6’2, TE Fred Davis 6-4 , both excelled last year tremendously; this year w/ McNabb they should excell even more and will be the talk all over soon.

    Marko Mitchell 6-4, and Malcolm Kelly 6-5, are all tall receivers waiting to explode as well; Kelly suffered injuries and his development has been slower; Marko Mitchell is a big target (7th round pick) could be the next Colston (from Saints) who was selected in the 6th round, and has become a very productive receiver…. watch out for Marko Mitchell, he is very talented, he is a baller!

    Is our time, time to develope our own stars, not seek other team’s stars like a Brandon Marshall, who’s to say the next Brandon Marshall is not going to be Kelly, Mitchell or Thomas…. there is plenty of talent in those players, all that needs to happen is have the ball thrown their direction!

    Crazy to wasted draft picks on selectin or trading for a WR? hey if the skins want to try a big veteran WR there are a couple out there that can be paid the minimum…. hmmm you guys might know who I’m refering to, hey if its the minimum pay, why not? Shannahan has demanded commitment and discipline, and whoever wants to stick with the team, better get w/ the program, because Shanny won’t hesitate to tell you byeeee!

  • Moondog

    Nice to see young redskins fans like the author. It’s been a brutal decade to be one.

    That being said, encourage you to do a bit more fact checking to support some of your premises.

    “What a bust that deal was, Haynesworth sat on the sideline a majority of the year.”

    Not ready to call this a bust yet myself. Am I thrilled about all things AH? No. However, we finally got some sacks out of our DEs with AH in 2009. All that oxygen he was sucking and limping trips to the sideline during 2009 may have given the impression he road the bench a lot, however, that’s not the case.

    Pat Williams: 570 snaps (18 games, 31.7/gm)
    Haloti Ngata: 630 snaps (16 games, 39.4/gm)
    John Henderson: 651 snaps (16 games, 40.7/gm)
    Marcus Stroud: 822 snaps (16 games, 51.4/gm)
    Jay Ratliff: 851 snaps (18 games, 47.3/gm)
    Kevin Williams: 987 snaps (18 games, 54.8/gm)
    Albert Haynesworth: 573 snaps (12 games, 47.8/gm)

    “As mentioned earlier, Campbell had a terrible season last year”

    Actually, statistically, Campbell didn’t have a terrible year. It was pretty comparable to McNabb’s.

    Happy for the changes made so far since the end of 2009 season and agree with you that, hopefully, this could be the start of something momentous for the skins. Been a long time coming.

    Hope Campbell lands somewhere that treats him better. Class guy and he deserves a second chance.

    HTTR!

  • http://sportschump.net Chris Humpherys

    Nice to see Moondog making the rounds.

    I agree. I can definitely see where the McNabb deal is best for both parties involved. It gives him a fresh start on a new team and Philly will finally find out what they’ve wondered about for years… whether life A.D. (After Donovan) is all it’s cracked up to be.

    http://sportschump.net/2010/04/08/chumpservations-vol-10-donovan-mcnabb-to-the-redskins-duke-as-national-champions-and-the-burden-of-jason-heyward/3422/

  • mgginva

    What the skins needed was exactly what came in, i.e. Shanny, Allen and McNabb.
    Fat Albert was out of shape last year – even he says so – but so was Portis, etc. AH needs an attitude adjustment but I’d still keep him. He’s a monster.
    The coaching and management in DC has been just frickin horrible for years.
    McNabb offers some serious leadership which JC just couldn’t offer. JC is a good guy but the team needs a leader and someone that does what he asks other players to do.
    The value McNabb brings is not just his slightly better QB ranking, but his hugely better presence on and off the field.
    The skins lost key players last year and didn’t have the depth to respond.
    Shanny’s cleaning house and if he can plug up our O line we should be ok.
    For a team that came to greatness on the Hogs – arguably the best ever O line, the skins have done little to keep up that tradition and haven’t understood it’s not the stars, it’s the lines that win year in and year out.
    I would use every pick we have until we get a great O line again! It isn’t a coincidence that of the top 8 picks 4 could very well be OT’s.
    Look what happened to Rypien after Gibbs found a way to protect him – he went from crapola to very good. Gibbs won with mediocre QB’s because he had great protection for them.
    We don’t need receivers – we need time – Donny – with enough time will find someone – plus we need to use the long ball a lot more – and again that means time.
    If Shanny can deal his way into a couple great tackles and maybe a safety, I think we can move up a spot in the NFC east.
    The other thing I find funny is that every one that trashes this trade and says DM wasn’t worth what we paid always says a 2nd and a 3rd pick were the price – well we need him to play 70% of the time and win 9 games to go from 4th to 3rd and I’d be happy with that.
    Philly – thanks again. See you next season when fat Albert crushes your golden boy.

advertisement


advertisement

Also in Sports